An earthworks and road infrastructure company with dozens of employees let its workers drive company vehicles from remote sites to their homes and back each morning. It added the car benefit (shovi shimush) to the payslips of its managers only. After an audit of 2018 to 2021, the Sharon area assessing officer issued an assessment by order covering everyone else. On 10 November 2026 the Central-Lod District Court dismissed the company's appeal and ordered it to pay ₪40,000 in costs.
Judge Shmuel Bornstein's ruling sets no new precedent. What it does is walk through, one by one, the arguments that fail an employer who leaves vehicles with its staff.
A written ban and a tracker were not enough
The company said its sites are far from public transport and that many of its workers live in scattered Bedouin communities, so a shared shuttle was not practical. Workers were told not to use the vehicles privately, it argued, and every vehicle carried an Ituran tracker that alerted on weekend movement. In its view that was the same as parking the fleet in its own yard.
The court went back to section 2(2) of the Income Tax Ordinance, which counts as employment income the value of using a vehicle "placed at the employee's disposal". Availability is the whole test. It makes no difference whether the employee took private trips, how many, or whether they were skipped by choice or because the employer forbade them.
The judge relied on the Supreme Court's 2019 Or-Zach decision. There a law firm wanted the benefit computed from an onboard system that split private and business trips. The Supreme Court held that the formula in the regulations is binding and cannot be replaced by actual-use data, even when that data shows a lower figure.
When a vehicle counts as operational
The vehicle expense regulations exclude an "operational vehicle". One route into that definition is a vehicle that was not placed at any employee's disposal, serves only the business, and does not leave the place of business after working hours. The court held that driving home is enough to rule a vehicle out of that category. Hundreds of kilometres between the workers' homes and the company's car park did not change the outcome.
The company's evidence was thin as well. It filed no Ituran reports, no alerts, no record of action against workers who broke the rule, and not a single document setting out the ban. The judge added that even such evidence would not have helped, given the Supreme Court's ruling.
Twenty-two years without a demand is no defence
The company argued that it had not taxed the benefit since it was founded in 1999, that its annual returns were accepted, and that no one had objected. The court rejected the reliance claim: each tax year stands on its own, and the Tax Authority may change its position. Having been left alone so far creates no right to carry on.
Two more points came out of the ruling. Without proper records linking each vehicle to a specific employee, the assessing officer assigned the vehicles by salary, starting with the highest earner, each at that employee's own marginal tax bracket. And after the company objected, the officer raised the assessment because more vehicles turned up and interest and linkage were added. Section 152(b) of the Ordinance allows that.
What an employer with work vehicles should check
| Situation | What the court held |
|---|---|
| Employee drives the vehicle home at the end of the day | It was placed at the employee's disposal, and the benefit applies under the regulations |
| Private use is banned and a tracker is installed | Does not remove the charge |
| Vehicle stays at the business after hours | May qualify as operational, if the other conditions are met |
| No record of which vehicle goes with which employee | The officer assigns them by salary, highest first |
| Years with no comment from the Tax Authority | No protection for later years |
A small contractor, an installation company or a technicians' firm whose staff take a pickup home has to add the car benefit to each such employee's payslip and withhold tax on it. The only alternative the court left open is for the vehicles to return to the business every evening. A clear log of each vehicle and the employee it is assigned to avoids having the officer allocate it to the top salaries.
Employees who live in localities that carry a residence-based tax credit should have their residency certificates on file. The company in this case presented none, and the court noted that it can still prove its workers' eligibility.
Self-employed people who use their own car for work fall under different rules, where part of the running costs is deductible. The vehicle expenses guide covers how that works.