A 2.6x expense gap didn't let the ITA cut war compensation

· By the Slate desk

On July 2, 2026, the Israeli appeals committee that hears indirect-damage compensation cases from COVID, the Swords of Iron war and Operation Rising Lion upheld an appeal by a company that produces conferences and events for corporate clients. The Israel Tax Authority had cut the fixed-expense component of the company's Swords of Iron compensation, recalculating it from the expenses the company actually had. The committee, Adv. Liat Katzir Margalit and CPA Baruch Baruchi, sent the calculation back to the formula in the law.

The decision came up at a webinar held by the accounting firm Fahn Kanne in September 2026. CPA Ayala Gal of the firm said the Authority and the appeals committees do not publish Swords of Iron decisions in any orderly way, and that this one did get published. She added that the Authority still asks some businesses for receipts and a breakdown of fixed expenses in their Rising Lion claims, and she expects it to try the same with claims for Operation Roaring Lion, the 2026 war.

How the formula works

In the qualifying-expenses track, compensation has two parts: wages and fixed expenses. The fixed-expense part is a percentage of the business's inputs, meaning the expenses it reported for VAT. That percentage, called the coefficient, rises with the drop in turnover: 7% for a drop of 25% to 40%, up to 22% for a drop of more than 80%.

The law lets the director set a different coefficient if convinced that the business's fixed expenses are higher or lower than the formula assumes. Under the Swords of Iron law the new coefficient cannot exceed 1.5 times the regular one. Under Roaring Lion, according to Gal and to the track's page on the Kol Zchut rights site, it can be raised up to 2 times. A business that wants it raised needs receipts for every expense.

The cut, and the committee's own numbers

The claims covered October 2023 and November to December 2023. By the formula, the fixed-expense component came to NIS 101,155 for each period. The inputs the company entered in its claim, about NIS 8.3 million, struck the Authority as unusually high, so it examined the fixed expenses in detail: rent, management fees, municipal tax, electricity, bookkeeping, insurance and IT. It arrived at NIS 24,241 for October, and about NIS 23,000 for the second period after multiplying by the drop in turnover.

The committee ran its own figures from the company's 2023 financial statements and found fixed expenses of about NIS 28,300 a month. It added NIS 30,000 for the owner's work planning three events cancelled because of the war, since in a business that plans projects ahead, that work counts as an expense it could not avoid. Even after all that, the formula still gave roughly 2.6 times the actual expenses.

When the formula can be set aside

The committee called the formula "the main road." The power to change the coefficient works in both directions, but only in exceptional cases, where the gap between actual expenses and the formula's result is truly significant. It cited an earlier decision in which a gap of 3 times was not enough, and said the gap should be weighed in shekels as well as a ratio.

A further reason concerns what the legislature intended. During the legislative debate it was made clear that a 22% coefficient on inputs is higher than the fixed expenses of a typical Israeli business. In the committee's view, the legislature deliberately chose an especially broad definition, and the Authority has to take that into account before cutting. The company will receive NIS 101,155 for each period, with the balance due within 30 days plus linkage differentials and interest, and NIS 5,500 in costs.

Another argument by the company failed. Payments of about NIS 1.44 million to foreign suppliers, for services rendered abroad with no invoice produced for them, do not count as inputs in the formula. An October decision on a Tiberias hotel reached the same principle from the opposite side: compensation rests on what was reported for VAT, and the Authority does not substitute a calculation of its own.

Ready to issue your first invoice?

Slate is free to use with no limits, Israel Invoice integration included. No credit card, no trial that runs out.

Open a Free Account